Full disclosure: I
have neither read any of the A Song of Ice and Fire series nor have I watched a
single episode of the Game of Thrones.
All that I know of it comes from listening to The Sword and from social
medial.
From The Sword, an Austin-hipster act relying on classic
metal riffs and lyrics taken from fantasy novels from the likes of Robert E.
Howard’s Conan and Kull series as well as George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Fire
and Ice series to give them something more than just Norse mythology to mine
for ideas, I have not been able to catch the story. “To Take the Black” was written about the
Night’s Watch and “Maiden, Mother, and Crone” references the three female faces
of the god of the Faith of the Seven.
There’s certainly speculation that other songs by The Sword were
inspired by this (“Winter’s Wolves,” for example). It seems The Sword is just as obsessed with
George R. R. Martin as Led Zeppelin was with J. R. R. Tolkien. (Hmm, is there something about having two
middle initials, both being the letter ‘R’, that makes your fantasy novels
fodder for rock tunes?)
The rest that I know about the series comes from cryptic
posts on Facebook and a plethora of stories posted on various internet sites on
Monday mornings. One of the things I’ve
found is that for a series based on a set of books, many people have not
bothered to read them, or the condensed Reader’s Digest version, or even the
Cliff’s Notes and are shocked and surprised by things other people are expecting. The other surprising thing I’ve noticed is
that for a story that contains swords, direwolves, and dragons, there is an
awful lot of sex, politics, betrayal, and murder. It seems to me to be a lot like a fantasy
soap opera.
So I asked a friend of mine, Liz Khimani, about the
show. I know she’s read the books but
doesn’t seem to have been following the show religiously. She claims that HBO has done a good job of
making the show interesting by hitting the key elements of the books: swords
and boobs. If they had just gone ahead
and named the damned thing “Swords and Boobs” I would have watched them all by
now. Here’s her tl;dr description of the
story:
“Well basically, the Lannisters are terrible people with one sort-of exception. The Starks are our heros [sic] but most of them have been murdered. The Tyrells are nicer, but also very politically savvy. The dragon owning lady is kind of just a teenager who doesn't really know what she's doing but is against slavery generally. The Bolton's [sic] are bastards in every sense of the word.”
“Well basically, the Lannisters are terrible people with one sort-of exception. The Starks are our heros [sic] but most of them have been murdered. The Tyrells are nicer, but also very politically savvy. The dragon owning lady is kind of just a teenager who doesn't really know what she's doing but is against slavery generally. The Bolton's [sic] are bastards in every sense of the word.”
So it seems to me that this is just a classic, 80s,
primetime soap. This whole cultural
phenomenon is nothing more than Dynasty of the Rings.
So now I’m wondering if one of those websites like Gawker,
Buzzfeed, or Upworthy, those sites whose articles contain no useful content and
are nothing but clickbait, have ever done an article comparing the families
from Game of Thrones to the families from the classic, 80s primetime
soaps. Are the Starks the Ewing family from
Dallas? Are the Lannisters the Quinns of
The Catlins? Are the Boltons the Barnes?
I don’t know. I
haven’t watched any of those shows.
No comments:
Post a Comment